Ban Damage: NV Reality of smoking ban sets in Page 3
NV Reality of smoking ban sets in, Kitchens closing, workers losing jobs
American Cancer Society drops appeal over convention center smoking
By Cy Ryan (contact)
Aug. 5, 2011
CARSON CITY – The American Cancer Society has dropped its appeal to the Nevada Supreme Court in a fight over allowing smoking in the Las Vegas Convention Center.
The American Cancer Society, which opposes smoking because of the health hazards, signed a stipulation this week with the Las Vegas Convention and Visitors Authority to dismiss its 2009 suit due to a law approved by the 2011 Legislature.
The Legislature passed and the governor signed a bill this year permitting smoking in the convention center under certain conditions.
The law allows smoking in the convention center if an event is closed to the public, if it was produced by a business with ties to tobacco or a professional association for convenience stores, or if it has displays of tobacco products.
The Legislature in 2009 passed a similar exemption, but it was combined with a bill on stalking. The Cancer Society challenged that law, arguing that it violated the constitutional prohibition of having two subjects in one bill.
But Carson City District Judge James Wilson rejected the argument of the Cancer Society, which then appealed to the Supreme Court.
The Cancer Society and the LVCVA filed opening and answering briefs earlier this year, but the Legislature in the final two days of the session in June approved the smoking exemption bill that deals with only one subject.
It Can Be Done
By Frank Davis
cfrankdavis.wordpress.com
CARSON CITY – Despite opposition from health officials, taverns and standalone bars have won the right to permit both smoking and food service under a bill signed into law Friday by Gov. Brian Sandoval.
Read more.
Governor signs bill to allow smoking in standalone bars that serve food
By Cy Ryan
?
Panel OKs bill to allow bar patrons to smoke and eat
Jun. 1, 2011
By Ed Vogel, LAS VEGAS REVIEW-JOURNAL CAPITAL BUREAU
CARSON CITY — A move to allow taverns and bars to let patrons smoke and eat meals if children are not allowed on the premises gained momentum Wednesday under a bill approved 10-5 by the Assembly Ways and Means Committee.
Under Assembly Bill 571, if only adults 21 and older are allowed to enter, taverns and bars can permit smoking and serve patrons food.
The bill revises the voter-approved Clean Indoor Air Act of 2006, which bans smoking in restaurants, taverns and most other places where food is served. Voter-approved laws can be amended by the Legislature after three years.
Under the bill, taverns and bars also could offer two sections: one where adults could smoke and eat, and a second, completely enclosed, no-smoking area for families and adults who prefer that option.
“This would help out our industry,” said Sean Higgins, a lobbyist for tavern owners. “We have been hit with a double whammy, the recession and the no-smoking law.”
But Paul Hackett, who represents the American Cancer Society and smoking prevention groups, said the bill violates the will of voters.
“They are expanding the areas where smoking is allowed,” he said.
Hackett thinks that the amended bill will lead to sports bars and large taverns creating both smoking and nonsmoking sections. Because the doors will be opening and closing, he thinks second-hand smoke would filter into the nonsmoking section.
Ways and Means Chairwoman Debbie Smith, D-Sparks, opposed the bill.
She said it might take some time for the amended bill to get to the Assembly floor for approval of the amendment and a vote.
If it receives Assembly approval, then the proposal must go to the Senate for additional hearings. The session ends at 1 a.m. Tuesday, so the proposal might die.
Smith said that the Clean Indoor Air Act has worked “very well” in Washoe County and that changing the law goes against the wishes of voters. During hearings, witnesses said enforcement of the no-smoking law has been spotty in Clark County.
Higgins expects the bill, introduced May 20, will become law.
He maintains that the measure offers taverns and patrons freedom of choice.
“For some, children are a small part of their clientele,” Higgins said of businesses that would be affected by the law. “The business operators will have to make a choice.”
All six Republicans on the Assembly committee voted for the bill, while five of the nine Democrats opposed it. Voting no were Smith; Paul Aizley, D-Las Vegas; Kelvin Atkinson, D-North Las Vegas; David Bobzien, D-Reno; and April Mastroluca, D-Henderson.
By Scott Wyland AND Laura Myers
Business loss kills more workers than they claim SHS does!
Now, let’s suppose it is true that secondhand smoke causes 53,000 premature deaths each year among the 200 million nonsmokers in the USA,? if that claim were true, then secondhand smoke would cause the premature deaths of at most 2.5/10,000 hospitality workers in our region each year. But, if one reads ? it becomes clear that every 1% decline in income causes the premature deaths of 2.1/10,000 persons each year among NV hospitality workers…and contrary to secondhand smoke studies, which have mixed results, there are no studies contradicting the impact of income loss on life expectancy.
So, let’s suppose the NV ban caused a 20% decline in business.. THEN, 20% multiplied by 2.1 premature deaths/ 10,000 hospitality workers= 42 premature deaths/ 10,000 in NV, among those bar workers each year due to income loss. Compare that to the 2.5/ 10,000 they claim might be prematurely dying from secondhand smoke exposure each year, and we can easily see that if these NV bars are losing 20% of their business, then the smoking ban is about 16 times more deadly for those workers than the smoke was, due to income loss.? ( this does not take into account that most bar workers are first-hand smokers. So actually, even if smoke prematurely kills nonsmokers, shs exposure to most bar workers who are smokers would not matter)
This is a rough calculation that makes assumptions. factually, business loss health impact estimates might not be quite be this bad; on the other hand it might actually be even worse.? But most of the health claim assumptions made here are not mine, but those of antismoking activists.?
– Dave Kuneman
No smoking at the tobacco show
More folly from local Nanny Staters
December 24, 2009
The Tobacco Plus Expo and the Retail Tobacco Dealers convention (the latter held at the Sands Expo and Convention Center) drew 27,000 attendees with a $41 million economic impact over the past six years, according to the Las Vegas Convention and Visitors authority.
But last year, due to Nevada’s Draconian law against indoor smoking, exhibitors and attendees at the Tobacco Plus Expo — scheduled to return to the Convention Center in March — were not allowed to sample tobacco products.
Near the end of the 2009 Legislature, lawmakers repaired that problem with a modest patch. Amending a bill already in the works to limit stalking, they added an amendment to AB309 to allow smoking at tobacco conventions.
Now comes the American Cancer Society with a lawsuit. Because the measure was added as an amendment to the anti-stalking measure, it violates the state constitution’s single-subject rule, the society claims.
In fact, the prohibitionists appear to have read the constitution incorrectly. The single-subject provision was installed to block voter initiatives which contain hidden, “Trojan horse” provisions. It has never before been considered a limit on lawmaking by the elected legislators.
“The title of the law refers to smoking and stalking as the crimes,” Legislative Counsel Bureau Director Lorne Malkiewich said. “There are many laws passed that include more than one crime.”
This lawsuit is likely to fail. At which point, the courts should order the prohibitionists to reimburse the convention authority and Nevada’s taxpayers their legal costs. But more important is what this effort again demonstrates.
It would be an understatement to say the tobacco prohibition zealots — this latest effort demonstrates once again their goal is step-by-step prohibition, not merely “protecting the children,” who tend to be thin on the ground at tobacco conventions — don’t give a hoot about Nevada’s jobs or economy. Look at all the kitchen and food-service workers who lost their jobs when the smoking ban hit bars and taverns.
Now, with Nevada still up to our armpits in the worst recession in half a century, the zealots want to reverse a modest and common-sense attempt to keep tobacco conventions heading this way by allowing attendees — adults who have paid to be there — to sample exhibitors’ perfectly legal wares?
That’s like saying your booze and lingerie conventions are welcome in Saudi Arabia — though of course no one in attendance will actually be allowed to taste the hooch or see the underwear.
This is Nevada. Those who don’t like gaming, drinking, smoking and a host of other adult activities long tolerated here have 49 other states to choose from. But that’s precisely what they can’t stand, isn’t it — the thought that somewhere, even if it’s far away in some remote and forbidding desert, adults may be participating in a consensual activity of which they do not approve.
From:? XXX
Sent:? 12/24/2009 07:57:29 AM
To:? contactus@emailcenter.cancer.org>
Subject:? American Cancer Society
http://www.lasvegasnow.com/Global/story.asp?S=11716731
———- Forwarded message ———-
From: American Cancer Society – Contact Us undl@emailcenter.cancer.org>
Date: Thu, Dec 24, 2009 at 1:18 PM
Subject: RE: American Cancer Society
http://acs.emailsurvey.sgizmo.com/?aid=1-2I0WGRE
Online Cancer Information Specialist
Bar owners disagree with research
By RICHARD LAKE, LAS VEGAS REVIEW-JOURNAL
The smoking ban did not hurt business in Southern Nevada, a study released Monday by UNLV researchers concluded.
Bill softening Nevada smoking ban passes Legislative committee
Bill easing smoking ban endorsed
04/08/2009
CARSON CITY, Nev. — A bill that would ease the terms of a voter-approved measure that banned smoking in many Nevada bars and other public places was approved on a 6-1 Wednesday by a key legislative committee.
Herbst Gaming talking restructuring
Dec. 06, 2008
By HOWARD STUTZ LAS VEGAS REVIEW-JOURNAL
Herbst Gaming said late Thursday it is discussing a restructuring agreement with its lenders after missing a $5.1 million interest payment earlier in the week.
In a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission, the locals gaming company also extended its forbearance and standstill agreement with its banks until Feb. 2 in an effort to restructure $846.8 million in debt.
Meanwhile, Herbst Gaming said it lost $101.2 million in the first nine months of 2008, compared with a net loss of $34.1 million for the same period a year earlier.
Herbst, which is privately held by brothers Ed, Tim and Troy Herbst but has public debt, operates 15 casinos in Nevada and the Midwest and a 7,200-slot machine route operation.
In March, the company said it was facing bankruptcy unless it could restructure its debt. Negotiation deadlines have been extended several times this year.
Gaming analysts expect the company to file bankruptcy, or possibly, a prepackaged bankruptcy in which the Herbst brothers would give up control over parts of the business.
Herbst grew significantly in 2007, acquiring casinos in Northern Nevada and completing a $394 million purchase of the three Primm Casinos from MGM Mirage. Also, the company finished an expansion to its Terrible’s Casino on East Flamingo Road.
However, the company’s gaming revenues were ravaged by a statewide voter-enacted ban on smoking in restaurants and taverns. Herbst’s slot route operations lost business; through September, revenues from routes were $186.9 million, down 12 percent compared with $212.5 million for the first nine months of 2007.
The company’s casino operations in Primm were hurt this year because high gasoline prices kept visitors from Southern California from making the drive on Interstate 15. Still casino revenues companywide have increased 4 percent in the first nine months of the year.
The company’s nine-month loss stems from an operating loss of $16.7 million and interest expenses of $85.3 million.
Black closes Oasis’ casino
Dec. 03, 2008
By ARNOLD M. KNIGHTLY LAS VEGAS REVIEW-JOURNAL
Cost-cutting move will trim company work force by 500
Mesquite operator Black Gaming will temporarily close the Oasis’ casino, restaurants and night clubs on Friday in a cost-cutting move for the financially struggling company.
The closing will cut the company’s work force by 500, according to a Monday filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
The Oasis’ 900-room hotel, RV park, neighboring golf course, gun club and time-share facilities will remain open.
Majority owner and Chief Executive Officer Randy Black Sr. said Tuesday the company wants to drive customers to its other two properties: the 480-room CasaBlanca and the 710-room Virgin River.
“We’re all hopeful the economy comes back,” Black said. “Because, if it doesn’t, things are just going to get worse.”
While the filing’s language described the move as temporary, an accompanying statement signed by Black warned “the length and depth of the challenging gaming market” means “no assurances can be made about” when the Oasis’ facilities would be reopened.
Black Gaming’s third-quarter revenues dropped 23.6 percent with the property showing a negative cash flow of $900,000.
Visitor volume to the town 80 miles northeast of Las Vegas is down 6.6 percent through September, with occupancy rates down 5.5 percent, according to the Las Vegas Convention and Visitors Authority.
Daily room rates for the city dropped 35.8 percent through September, and gaming revenues are down 9.9 percent, according to the visitors authority.
Mesquite Mayor Susan Holecheck said the loss of 500 jobs in a city of 20,000 surrounded by smaller communities is devastating anytime of year but especially at Christmastime.
“Laying off 500 people has a huge domino effect,” Holecheck said. “At Christmastime, if people are out of a job and not making money, then they are not able to go to the stores and restaurants. If people don’t have the money, they in turn aren’t helping our businesses.”
The Oasis will give the laid-off workers a packet with information on applying for social services such as unemployment and food stamps, Marty Rapson, Black Gaming’s marketing vice president, said Tuesday.
The workers will also be put on a list to be rehired when the property reopens, Rapson said.
Before the layoffs, CasaBlanca, Oasis and Virgin River ranked as the top three employers in Mesquite with a combined 2,278 workers, according to a city economic development report released in April.
The company will have approximately 1,500 workers following the layoffs, according to Monday’s federal filing.
The Oasis will keep a few slot machines open at the front counter to maintain the property’s nonrestricted gaming license.
The property began shutting down the casino’s table games on Monday and will continue to phase out casino and restaurant operations this week.
The restaurants will close Friday after dinner, Rapson said, but no time has been set.
The company’s ability to close portions of the Oasis was part of a Nov. 3 update to a bank agreement after it defaulted on a loan.
The current bank agreement expires Jan. 15, which means it would have to be updated if the Oasis’ facilities remain closed past that date.
Black said the company is negotiating with the banks, but no decision as been made on what will be done in January.
Black Gaming is operating under $188.7 million in debt with interest rates near double digits.
Black is also getting hurt by his sole competition — the 215-room Eureka hotel-casino which recently completed a $30 million expansion and renovation.
Black said this year that “the other guy” controls 30 percent of the market.
Majority-owned by Las Vegas real estate developers the Lee Family, the Eureka added 300 new slot machines, expanded its buffet, and added a new poker room and new sports book.
News from Vegas only getting worse
Precipitous drop in gambling revenue guts casino stocks
July 10, 2008
By William Spain, MarketWatch
CHICAGO (MarketWatch) — Casino stocks were battered again Thursday, with shares of the big players scraping to multiyear lows on the back of news of a precipitous drop in Nevada’s gambling revenue.
Statewide, gambling revenue in May slumped 15%, with a roughly similar pace of decline in table games and slot machines alike. Things were even worse on the Las Vegas Strip, where total gambling revenue fell 16.4% — the largest decline yet in 2008, and one that is at an increasing rate as quarter-to-date revenues for the Strip are off 9%.
“The decline in Strip revenues is worse than the period immediately following Sept. 11, 2001 and except for January 2002 is the worst monthly performance in more than 10 years,” analyst Robin Farley of UBS wrote in a research report. “The weakness in gaming revenues was not confined exclusively to the Strip as the Las Vegas locals market declined 19.5% in May, bringing year to date revenues down 8.7%.”
The figures brought another round of pain to shareholders of the gambling giants, as MGM Mirage (MGM: 23.14 -6.44 -21.77% 4:01pm 07/10/2008)? fell nearly 22% to $23.14, its lowest mark since late 2005; Las Vegas Sands Corp. (LVS: 34.01 -4.12 -10.81%? 4:00pm 07/10/2008 ) was taken down 11% to $34.015, a three-year-low; and Wynn Resorts Ltd. (WYNN 69.94, -7.62, -9.8%) was off 9.8% to a level not seen since 2006? Boyd Gaming Corp (BYD 9.28, -0.66, -6.6%? 4:04pm 07/10/2008) , which specializes in the Las Vegas locals market but is in the process of building its multibillion dollar Echelon property, fell more than 6% to $9.28.
By way of contrast, last fall MGM shares cracked $100 at one point; Sands was nearly $150; Wynn traded above $176 and Boyd hit almost $55.
Joe Greff of J.P. Morgan said a reporting method includes the slot drop from the last two days in May, but not the win, reduced revenue by roughly $10.5 million for the month, but “we note that even after adjusting for this issue, results on the Strip were still pretty ugly.”
‘People are just staying closer to home.’ — Nick Danna, Stern Agee & Leach
Then, after the market closed on Thursday, Wynn Resorts said it expects Las Vegas operating income to drop by two-thirds to the $18 million to $22 million range, compared with $63.4 million last year. In Macau, however, operating income is expected to be in the range of $100 million to $106 million, compared with $53.2 million in the year-ago period, the company said.
Revenue away from the casino floor, now typically more than half of the total at most Strip resorts, also have been under pressure as cash-strapped airlines hike fares and cut capacity at McCarran International Airport. That in turn pushes down room rates and occupancy levels while leading to lower spending by visitors who do come.
“The decline appears to be accelerating,” said Nick Danna, an analyst with Stern Agee & Leach. “Their reliance on nongaming revenue is really hurting them,” as the spend per visitor drops.
He sees no immediate end in sight either: “We are recommending that investors avoid the Las Vegas-centric stocks as it appears that market is performing worse than some of the regional ones. People are just staying closer to home.”
Jim Murren, president of MGM Mirage, remains relatively sanguine and thinks that the market reaction has been overblown.
“We go through cycles in hospitality, we go through cycles in Las Vegas,” he recently told MarketWatch. “There seems to be a kind of piling-on effect right now with folks worried about any of myriad issues. We think we have a handle on this. We have been through this before.”
He pointed out that the company is still running occupancy in the 90% range.
“Sure, we have had to lower rates to do that but we are filling up these rooms,” Murren said. “And we are generating strong profits. Are we making as much money as last year? No. But we are making more money than we did in 2005 and 2006, and we felt pretty good about ourselves back then.”
LasVegasAdvisor surveyed 84 casino-hotels and found that more than half had available rates of $50 or less in July
Total visitation to Las Vegas fell 1.5% in April, according to figures compiled by the Las Vegas Convention and Visitors Authority, which pushed the year-to-date figure to a dip of 0.1% while hotel occupancy levels fell 3.8% that month, or 1.7% since the start of 2008.
In his most recent survey, Greff at J.P. Morgan found that room rates on the Strip for the week of July 27 through August 2 plummeted 23% to an average of $156, with weekday rates down 24% and weekend rates off 20%. For the third quarter to date, rate are down 16% overall, compared with a 13% decline in the first quarter.
“We believe that the results of the survey reflect the impact of a slowing economy on travel to and spend on the Strip; it also reflects aggressive pricing/discounting of room rates,” he said. “When it stops is tough to forecast with any great precision, though we think this continues through the summer.”
A recent report by LasVegasAdvisor.com found that many resorts are discounting room rates to their lowest levels since 2003. The Web site surveyed 84 casino-hotels and found that more than half had available rates of $50 or less in July.
This isn’t just for the lower-tier hotels, it reported: “Despite efforts to disguise discounting on the high end, many of Las Vegas’ luxury resorts are slashing rates” as well as offering additional lures including meal credits, free play and even airfare and gasoline rebates.
That survey found prices below $90 at Luxor, MGM Grand, Flamingo, Hard Rock, Mirage, Palms, Planet Hollywood and Paris, while “a rate check of comparable accommodations in New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco and Orlando yielded only two hotels with a sub-$50 rate.”
Of course, any slump on the Strip ripples into the locals market, he added, leading to lower employment rates and more suffering in an already beaten-down housing market.
“We are seeing it across all market segments in Las Vegas, whether it is the tourist market or the locals market,” said Keith Smith, chief executive of Boyd Gaming. “Unemployment is up and lot of those people are our customers who come to [play] at our properties.”
William Spain is a MarketWatch staff writer in Chicago.
Nevada Taverns Refuse to Obey Nevada Smoking ban
Two years ago — when the economy was humming along fine and nobody was getting hepatitis C from a colonoscopy ?— Nevada’s proposed indoor smoking ban was front-page news.
Read More:? NV Reality of smoking ban sets in Page 2