People Ban: TN State Update Page 3
Humphrey: What about that cigarette stomp?
By Tom Humphrey
Sunday, October 7, 2007?
To dramatize the state’s new smoking ban at a media event last week, Gov. Phil Bredesen pulled a cigarette our of his suit pocket, tossed it on the ground and stomped.
The cigarette, unlit, was one of those long, skinny types. The wind blew it a few inches on the parking lot pavement, and the governor, as the TV cameras recorded the action, missed on his first tromping attempt.
But he smeared it on the second try. Then Bredesen daintily picked up the remains and handed them to an aide, sidestepping any litterbug accusations tainting his symbolic kicking of the butt.
On first blush, this might seem the goofiest gubernatorial gimmick since big, bald Ned McWherter held a dinky little golden bell in his hand, then waved it up and down before TV cameras to “ring out for the children” in a display of support for education reform.
But perhaps it is better seen as another indication of the new, bold second-term Bredesen striving for dramatic flare as he works to build a legacy. The stomping was apparently his own idea, leaving some staffers a bit disconcerted.
There are some troubling aspects of the episode. For example, it is reliably reported that Bredesen had an aide mooch the cigarette from a waitress at the restaurant where the media show was being conducted.
Thus, multi-millionaire Phil’s foot was crushing a cigarette purchased by a working woman paying new, higher taxes and subject to arrest if she imported them from Kentucky. With cigarettes going at about $3.50 a pack, the single smoke was worth about 17.5 cents.
Was this a political contribution and, if so, will the governor – who has in the past made a point of reporting all donations, regardless of how small – list it on his next disclosure?
Or was it a gift, indicating special treatment of a particular elected official in violation of the general ban on gifts included in the state’s ethics laws?
The governor, of course, could avoid these troubling questions by buying his own cigarettes and paying the higher taxes, which, as you may recall, were approved to support education.
Then a statewide tour would be appropriate. At every town, the governor could hold a media event, pull out his pack of Virginia Slims, toss one on the ground and apply foot while reciting a new slogan: “Stomp one out for the kids!”
If this caught on with other nonsmokers, there could be statewide stomp-out parties, boosting sales and state revenue from the cigarette tax. As you may have heard, cigarette tax revenues were $14 million short of expectations during the first month of the new 62-cents-per-pack tax rate.
This would be fighting against tobacco while boosting state revenue for the children at the same time.
It would resolve the dilemma now facing our state of waging war on cigarettes while depending on them for revenue.
In other words, our governor is pretty darn clever. As he is prone to say, folks ought not see a problem as being resolved in one of two ways – say the Republican way or the Democratic way – but should always seek a third way.
Yes, this is the bold new Bredesen. There should be more symbolic and dramatic gubernatorial gestures in the future.
For example, the governor made a mistatement a while back in saying that some new and tougher laws on drunken driving – recommended by a task force he appointed – had passed the Legislature. They hadn’t but will be up for consideration next year.
The new, bold Bredesen should hold a news conference and crush an empty beer can against his head just before stepping into his car.
This would dramatize his stance against mixing alcohol and driving. And perhaps serve as a reminder, rather like tapping your head to recall a thought, that the bill hasn’t passed yet.
The anti-obsesity campaign, another awareness-raising venture that has Bredesen’s blessing, raises another possibility.
Call it Trash the Trans-Fat.
Imagine the inspiration of seeing our governor pull out a bag of glazed donuts, take one out, rip it to shreds, crush it into a ball and toss it in a big trash can as the TV cameras roll.
Naturally, he would then pull out a carrot and munch on it while fielding questions about fighting fat.
Tom Humphrey, chief of the News Sentinel’s Nashville bureau, may be reached at 615-242-7782 or tomhumphrey3@aol.com.
————-
Posted by nycclash on October 7, 2007 at 2:48 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Love the wit. Well done.
As for Gov. Bredesen, it would have been more accurate if he threw a smoker down on the floor and stomped on his face. Cigarettes don’t smoke themselves. People do. Unless the governor wants to start a new false claim that unlit cigarettes are dangerous too? What? They’ll poke an eye out?
And so the implication is more of the new and approved hate campaign. It’s open season on smokers. There are plenty of incidents of smokers being assaulted verbally and physically and more who just need that nod that it’s okay to begin doing the same. The governor’s behavior sanctions it. And the disturbing part is that he probably wouldn’t see anything wrong with it once the message his behavior sends was pointed out to him.
Audrey Silk
Founder, NYC Citizens Lobbying Against Smoker Harassment (NYC C.L.A.S.H.)
Brooklyn, NY
Statewide smoking ban goes into effect today
Law getting mixed reactions from business owners, public
By Tom Humphrey (Contact)
•?Private homes, private residences and private motor vehicles, unless used for child care.
•?Non-enclosed areas of public places including open air patios, porches or decks; any that are enclosed by garage-type doors when all such doors are open; and any that are enclosed by tents or awnings with removable sides or vents when all such sides or vents are removed or open. Smoke must not reach areas where smoking is prohibited.
•?Venues that restrict access to people who are at least 21 years old.
•?Private businesses with three or fewer employees, where smoking may be allowed only in an enclosed room not accessible to the general public. Smoke must not reach areas where smoking is prohibited.
•?Private clubs.
•?Smoking rooms in hotels and motels; no more than 25 percent of rooms in a hotel or motel may be designated as smoking rooms.
•?Tobacco manufacturers, importers and wholesalers.
•?Retail tobacco stores that prohibit minors.
•?Nursing homes and long-term-care facilities, which are subject to the policies and procedures established by those facilities.
•?Commercial vehicles when the vehicle is occupied only by the operator.
Source: Tennessee Department of Health
________________________________________
NASHVILLE — With a new statewide ban on smoking taking effect today, Douglas Benton planned to celebrate by dining in restaurants for breakfast, lunch and supper with family and friends.
“This is a great, great day for Tennessee,” said the Alcoa anti-smoking activist. “It is a monumental thing for the betterment of people’s lives. They will live better and longer without second-hand smoke.”
Rebecca Smith, however, doesn’t like the idea of government “trying to make me feel like I’m doing something wrong” by lighting a cigarette after a meal.
“I will not spend my money in a restaurant where they don’t allow smoking,” said the Crossville mother. “We keep giving away more and more of our rights and, before long, this is not going to be a free country any more.”
Tennessee’s “nonsmokers protection act” has several exceptions. For example, the smoking ban does not apply to businesses with three or fewer employees or restaurants and bars that require customers to be 21 or older.
Still, it does cover most public places and marks a major change for a tobacco-producing state that generally has been liberal in permitting puffing.
“I thought it would take at least 10 years for this to happen,” said Benton, who in 2005 founded a group called No Smoking In Restaurants.
Approved by the Legislature in May, the effective date of the smoking ban was delayed until today, with lawmakers saying they wanted to give everyone time to prepare.
Further, state Health Commissioner Susan Cooper said authorities will go light on enforcement as people adjust to the new law. Violators, both individuals and businesses, can expect written warnings rather than financial penalties — at least for now.
“You’re not going to see the smoking police come out,” Cooper said. “We’re going to use the first several months of this to help educate people. We believe people want to comply with the law, and we’ll work with them to help that process.”
The Department of Health will be responsible for enforcing the law in businesses that it inspects already, including restaurants and other businesses ranging from child care facilities to tattoo parlors.
The Department of Labor and Workforce Development will enforce the law in other places where people work.
Neither enforcement agency is hiring new workers to bolster enforcement. But agency inspectors, who visit most workplaces as part of their regular jobs, will be checking on compliance in the process, Cooper said.
For a person who puffs in the wrong place, the law provides a $50 fine.
For businesses that wrongfully allow smoking, the law requires only a warning on the first offense. For the second offense in a 12-month period, the fine is $100. For third and subsequent offenses, the fine is $500.
Those who want to report violators can do so starting today through the Department of Health’s Web site, health.state.tn.us, or by calling 800-293-8228, the commissioner said.
The department also is offering assistance to those who want to stop smoking through another number, 800-784-8669.
Surveys indicate that about 27 percent of adult Tennesseans, or about 1.6 million people, are smokers, the commissioner said. That is one of the highest percentages in the nation, she said.
The law has required restaurants and bars to decide whether they will ban customers under 21 years of age or ban smoking. While no one has taken a survey, Cooper and others said it appears that most have opted to ban smoking.
For example, Jennifer Nelson, a bartender at Old College Inn on Cumberland Avenue in Knoxville, said the establishment is banning smoking — except in an open-air patio area capable of seating about 25 people.
Nelson said she was concerned that the ban would reduce the number of customers, but “we’ll just have to wait and see.”
On the other hand, Joan Wilson, who owns The Hitching Post in Clinton, bans those under 21 and will allow smoking to continue. Most of her patrons are smokers, she said.
Wilson said the idea of a smoking ban “really, really makes me angry.”
“I just don’t think it’s right that they should be able to tell me what to do in my own business,” she said. “Smokers are being persecuted. Higher taxes and now this.”
The law that passed the Legislature actually was a compromise. Gov. Phil Bredesen and some legislators pushed a bill that would have been much stricter, providing fewer exceptions.
Bredesen said earlier this year that he sees the law as a “good first step” and hopes it can be strengthened in the future. But Lydia Lenker, spokeswoman for the governor, said any discussion of changes in the law would be “premature” and that Bredesen also believes new programs should be allowed to work.
Sen. Jim Tracy, R-Shelbyville, who was Senate sponsor of the bill that is now law, said lawmakers should wait “until everybody is acclimated to the law we have now” before making any changes. That will take at least four or five years, he said.
Cooper said that, as health commissioner, she would like to see exceptions repealed as steps toward “an ideal world where we would have a smoke-free Tennessee.”
“But you have to balance that with reality,” she said. “I think it will be nice to see where we go with the legislation that has passed.”
Rick Johnson, senior vice president of Ruby Tuesday, said the nationwide chain already has adapted to similar laws in other states with no real problems. As a “kid-friendly” business, Johnson said there was no real consideration of banning those under 21.
“We haven’t seen it have an impact on our business (in other states),” Johnson said. “If it’s applied across the board, it doesn’t keep people from coming to a restaurant they enjoy coming to.”
Tom Humphrey may be reached at 615-242-7782.
After decades of failed attempts, the tobacco state of Tennessee is finally about to enact its first workplace anti-smoking law on Oct. 1.
Patrons may breathe easier, but how will business owners cope?
by Mike Gibson
Photos by Sheena Patrick
9/30/2007
By: Stoney Sharp, Reporter
?
Well, it’s like this, WATE Channel 6 finally got the state to raise the cigarette tax and impose a smoking ban. So here are a few stories, but the first is about Congress and their topics that they come up with.
?
http://www.wate.com/Global/story.asp?s=6852793
?
This next story is a real doozey. The local law enforcement in Newport has no clue to what happened July 1, 2007. The tax hike started, but the smoking ban is not until Oct 1, 2007. I’m glad I don’t live in Newport; they probably would arrest the victim instead of the lawbreaker!
?
http://www.wate.com/Global/story.asp?s=6802428
?
And then last but least, I have said in the past, ever since the smoking ban talk started, that one day when they got finished with smoker’s, they would start on the drinker’s. Alleluia, I must be clairvoyant, or whatever they call people who can see the future, because brothers and sisters, the government is coming to our rescue. They want to insure that we do not smoke and do not drink. Darn, That was two of my vices and that only leaves one vice left. A person just can’t have fun any more with out BIG BROTHER messing things up.
?
http://www.wate.com/Global/story.asp?s=6863048
?
Okay my best guess is that next on the list will be either your car or your sex life, because there is not too much left.
?
Take care all
Robert F. Pritchard – mailto:info@yessir-tn.info
Southeast Regional Director of The Smoker’s Club, Inc.
YesSIR of Tennessee – http://www.yessir-tn.info
The Smoker’s Club, Inc. & Video Archive – http://www.smokersclub.com
Smokers Rights Newsletter – http://www.smokersclubinc.com
Smoky Mountain Sales – http://www.smoky-mountain-sales.com?
“In the End, we will remember not the words of our enemies, but the silence of our friends.”? – Martin Luther King Jr.
Eyewitness News Memphis – TN, USA
The smoking ban applies to restaurants, public and private schools, health care facilities, hotels and motels, retail stores and shopping malls and sports …
SI.com – USA
A smoking ban will take effect this fall at the University of Tennessee’s 102000-seat Neyland Stadium, the third-largest college football venue in the …
WVLT – Knoxville,TN,USA
The Governor signed the Workplace Smoking Ban into law Monday, with few exceptions. Medical Reporter Jessa Goddard looks at how the law will affect both …
Bredesen signs workplace smoking ban into law
Jackson Sun – Jackson,TN,USA
Bredesen, a Democrat, proposed a smoking ban in February as ”one of the single biggest things we can do to improve our health and leave our state with a …
WKRN – Nashville,TN,USA
By ERIK SCHELZIG AP Writer A legislative session dominated by the debate over _ and ultimate passage of _ a cigarette tax hike and a smoking ban was …
Jackson Sun – Jackson,TN,USA
A statewide smoking ban could soon be enforced in some workplaces and restaurants following its recent approval by the state legislature. …
Jackson Sun – Jackson,TN,USA
The smoking ban bill passed by the General Assembly last week, may not be perfect, but it is a workable compromise and a positive step forward. Gov. …
Nashville City Paper – Nashville,TN,USA
Eric Swafford (R-Pikeville) marveled on the House floor that the state Legislature was passing a smoking ban bill when just a few years ago similar measures …
WKRN – Nashville,TN,USA
Tennessee is following in the footsteps of other states around the country as a statewide workplace smoking ban is now on the way to Governor Bredesen. …
WATE.com – Knoxville,TN,USA
By AMELIA DANIELS. KNOXVILLE (WATE) — Despite opposition from tobacco lobbyists, a bill banning smoking in most workplaces is on its way to becoming law. …
Smoking-ban OK breaks Tennessee tradition
Dickson Herald – Dickson,TN,USA
By ERIK SCHELZIG. AP. A proposal to ban most workplace smoking — including in restaurants — passed the state House Agriculture Committee on Wednesday …
Jackson Sun – Jackson,TN,USA
|NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) — Most indoor smoking, including in restaurants, would be banned under a bill passed by the House on Thursday. …
Workplace smoking ban bill passes tobacco-friendly House panel
(2) All enclosed facilities within places of employment, including, but not limited to, common work areas, auditoriums, classrooms, conference and meeting rooms, private offices, medical facilities, cafeterias, employee lounges, and all other enclosed facilities. Enclosed facilities include buildings and vehicles, owned leased or operated by an employer. For purposes of this bill, a municipality or government entity is considered an employer, as is an individual and other business organizations
(3) The seating areas of all outdoor arenas, stadiums, and amphitheaters and bleachers and grandstands for use by spectators at sporting and other public events
(4) Within 20 feet outside entrances, operable windows, and ventilation systems of enclosed areas where smoking is prohibited.
(2) In sports arenas, including enclosed places in outdoor arenas
(3) Within 20 feet outside entrances, operable windows, and ventilation systems of enclosed areas where smoking is prohibited.
(2) Private residences, unless used as a childcare, adult day care, or medical facility
(3) The workplace of any employer with fewer than three employees, unless it is a public place; (4) Retail tobacco stores, so long as secondhand smoke does not escape into areas otherwise designated as being smoke-free
(5) Areas designated within and by long-term care facilities as smoking areas or for supervised patient smoking only
(6) Outdoor areas of places of employment
(7) All workplaces of any manufacturer, importer, or wholesaler of tobacco products, or any tobacco leaf dealer or processor, and all tobacco storage facilities
(8) Licensed restaurants and bars that do not allow anyone under the age of 18 into the establishment, so long as secondhand smoke does not escape into smoke-free areas and the establishments prominently post a health warning sign.
Nashville City Paper – Nashville,TN,USA
The House Agriculture Committee – long opposed to measures unfriendly to tobacco – approved a watered down version of a smoking ban bill today. …
TriCities.com – Johnson City,TN,USA
In fact, many insist a smoking ban should be all or nothing. Overall, most like Terry Russo, say the government should just butt-out. …
Cookeville Herald Citizen – Cookeville,TN,USA
COOKEVILLE — Most restaurant and bar owners as well as managers in Cookeville see nothing wrong with a statewide workplace smoking ban as long as no …
WBIR-TV – Knoxville,TN,USA? 5/24/07
Smoking would be banned in Tennessee restaurants and most workplaces under a bill that passed the state Senate by a wide margin today. …
The Tennessean – Nashville,TN,USA
With several versions of a proposed workplace smoking ban being considered in the Senate, a House committee chose to delay its vote on a workplace ban today …
WBIR-TV – Knoxville,TN,USA
The idea that a broad smoking ban would get as far as it has this year at the Capitol seems remarkable to many. It was only a few years ago that smoking was …
commercialappeal.com (subscription) – Memphis,TN,USA
Senators voted 15-12 to adopt an amendment that would enact the more comprehensive smoking ban favored by the Smoke-Free Tennessee Coalition and Gov. …
By LUCAS L. JOHNSON II, Associated Press Writer
Read More:? TN State Update Page 2
Read More:?
